Comparing Different Parking Lot Paving Options

Comparing Different Parking Lot Paving Options

A parking lot is more than just a place to keep your vehicle. It’s an extension of your property and plays a crucial role in maintaining the safety of your occupants and visitors.

In the United States, for example, it’s estimated that there are two billion parking spaces—10% of which are paid facilities. It might not look like it, but the industry earned USD$ 121 billion (GBP£ 94.88 billion) in 2022.

Asphalt is the most popular parking lot surface, but different paving options might interest you. In this article, we’ll explore the most popular choices and compare each by discussing their pros and cons. You’ll also discover the essential considerations to help you make an informed decision.  

Asphalt: The Popular Choice

Think paved parking lots, and asphalt is the first thing that comes to mind. This dark, petroleum-based material is a popular choice for several reasons:


Asphalt boasts a lower upfront cost compared to other options, making it ideal for larger parking areas. Hiring a reliable asphalt paving service provider helps ensure you’re getting the most out of your project. These companies offer cost-efficient yet excellent preparation, construction, maintenance, and repair solutions. 

Better Traction

Asphalt parking lots provide a smooth, comfortable driving experience for your customers. It also has higher skid resistance, making it safer than concrete.

Quick Installation and Easy to Repair

Asphalt paving can be completed relatively quickly, minimizing downtime for your business. Cracks and potholes can be repaired relatively easily and inexpensively. If you’re worried about the carbon footprint of asphalt production, choose a paving company that provides eco-friendly solutions like recycling. 

Less Sensitive to Cold Temperatures

Asphalt performs well in colder climates, as it’s less prone to cracking from freezing temperatures.


Despite being the most popular choice, asphalt has its drawbacks. These include:

Frequent Maintenance

Sealcoating is required every three to five years. It’s crucial to maintain asphalt’s integrity and prevent cracks.

High Heat Absorption

Asphalt tends to absorb heat more readily, which can be uncomfortable in hot climates.

Shorter Lifespan

Compared to concrete, asphalt typically has a shorter lifespan of around 40 years before needing replacement.

Concrete: The ‘Tough’ Candidate

If durability is your top priority, concrete might be your champion. This strong, weather-resistant material is known for its ability to withstand heavy traffic and harsh conditions:

Built to Last

Concrete boasts a longer lifespan of up to 75 years compared to asphalt, making it a cost-effective option in the long run.

Low Maintenance

A concrete parking lot requires less frequent maintenance than asphalt, with occasional crack repairs being the main concern.

Heat Reflective

Unlike asphalt, concrete reflects heat, making it a cooler option for hot climates.


But concrete isn’t perfect for every parking lot for the following reasons:

Higher Initial Cost

Concrete has a higher upfront cost compared to asphalt.

Rough Ride

Concrete can provide a slightly rougher driving experience compared to smooth asphalt.

Crack Happens

While less frequent than asphalt, concrete can still develop cracks, especially in areas with freeze-thaw cycles.

Interlocking Pavers: A Great Aesthetic Option

Looking for a touch of sophistication for your parking lot? Consider interlocking pavers. These precast concrete or stone units offer a unique aesthetic and several practical benefits:

Design Flexibility

Pavers come in various colours, shapes, and patterns, allowing for creative design possibilities.

Drainage System Champs

The spaces between pavers allow for natural drainage, reducing water pooling.

Easy Repairs

Individual pavers can be replaced if damaged, minimizing repair costs.


However, pavers come with their own set of considerations:

Highest Cost

Interlocking pavers are the most expensive option on this list.

Installation Time

Installing pavers is a more time-consuming process compared to asphalt or concrete.

Weed Warrior

The spaces between pavers can be susceptible to weed growth, requiring regular maintenance.

Important Factors to Consider

Choosing the right parking lot paving material goes beyond just the materials themselves. Here are some additional factors to consider:

Traffic Volume

High-traffic areas will benefit from the durability of concrete, while lower-traffic areas might find asphalt sufficient.


Proper drainage is crucial to prevent water pooling and damage. Consider the natural slope of your land and choose a material that allows for proper water flow.


Asphalt performs well in cold climates, while concrete is better suited for hot climates.

Maintenance Budget

Factor in the ongoing maintenance costs associated with each material to ensure it aligns with your budget. For example, asphalt requires regular seal coating, while concrete might need occasional crack repair. Pavers are generally low-maintenance but require occasional cleaning and joint sand replenishment.


Remember to consider the visual impact of your parking lot. Pavers offer the most design flexibility, while concrete’s clean lines can create a modern look. Asphalt provides a classic, no-frills aesthetic.

Environmentally conscious individuals can ask for certain technologies that make each paving material more sustainable. We’ve earlier mentioned asphalt recycling. You can also inquire whether your preferred option supports green practices in the construction industry.

Making Your Choice

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer when it comes to parking lot paving. Based on the discussion above, here’s a quick cheat sheet to help you get started:

  • An asphalt parking lot is best if you need a budget-friendly option for a low-traffic area with a cold climate.
  • Concrete is worthwhile if you want long-term durability, lower maintenance costs, and are located in a hot climate.
  • Interlocking pavers might be worth the investment if you’re seeking a visually appealing option with easy repairs and good drainage.  

Considering the discussion above will help you choose the right material that aligns with your needs and preferences. More importantly, consulting a local paving contractor is a wise move. They can assess your specific needs and guarantee that your soil or ground conditions are ideal to make your parking lot project last. These specialists can help you pave the way for optimized functionality and appearance of your parking lot.

Comparing Different Parking Lot Paving Options

Latest Issue

BDC 317 : Jun 2024